Jean-Luis Ska has an interesting article that includes discussions of several textual variants in Genesis 18 that might be of interest.
This blog is intended to be an outlet for research and questions on the textual criticism of the Old Testament/Hebrew Bible and related issues.
Wednesday, October 28, 2026
Sunday, October 25, 2026
Klawans on Forgeries and Authentication
Jonathan Klawans has published a new book Biblical Forgery and Academic Authentication: Persisting Patterns of Guile and Gullibility on forgeries and the sketchy role scholars sometimes play in authentication of unprovenanced materials. It sounds like an interesting read for those who work with manuscripts, because there is a good chance someone will approach you at some point to authenticate a find. I can't even remember how many 3000-year-old Torah scrolls from Turkey have ended up in my inbox. It's good to think about these issues before they come up, rather than after the fact.
From the website:
- Informs, for the first time, on a wide-range of biblical forgery cases
- Focuses on issues relating to academic authentication: why scholars fall for forgeries and the poor arguments used to authenticate
- Introduces forgery studies and proposes a new "scale of authenticity," from 1 to 5
Biblical Forgery and Academic Authentication describes and decries the roles academics have played in the authentication of biblical forgeries. The most notorious recent incident is surely the 2016 publication of thirteen minuscule Dead Sea Scroll fragments displayed in the Museum of the Bible in Washington, DC, quickly determined to be clever forgeries. Additional episodes range from Cyrus Gordon's 1970s authentications of supposedly ancient Hebrew inscriptions discovered in America to more recent trusting re-evaluations of the suspicious Deuteronomy manuscripts offered for sale by Moses Wilhelm Shapira in 1883.
While various articles and books have focused on one incident or another, no recent monograph has tried to grasp the larger, repeating dynamic of academic naiveté among biblical scholars. Nor has any work on forgery to date isolated and illustrated the distinct role played by the academic authenticator-a figure who stands between forgers and skeptics, neither forging nor criticizing the artifacts they encounter and endorse. The inherently controversial act of authenticating unprovenanced finds occasionally coincides with other broken norms (undue secrecy, insufficient disclosures, at times with money involved). This book sheds new light on long-resolved forgery cases, to tip the balance in some open cases, and to expose the ethical and intellectual lapses that permit the current situation to persist and fester.
Wednesday, October 21, 2026
Reconstructed Koine Pronunciation
Sunday, October 11, 2026
Why aren't Torah scrolls vocalized?
Friday, October 9, 2026
CEHP Restart
Thursday, October 8, 2026
The Reformers on the Authority of the Septuagint
Tuesday, October 6, 2026
New Resource on the Samaritans and the Samaritan Pentateuch
I just learned of a new site/app put together by Osher Sassoni with lots of resources on the Samaritan community, their beliefs, and their tradition of the Pentateuch. Perhaps the most interesting part is that it includes vocalized Samaritan Pentateuch texts as well as audio-recordings of readings of the texts. There is also a large collection of freely available digital images of Samaritan manuscripts. It also includes variants from Von Gall's edition. This looks to be a useful tool for those studying the Samaritans and their biblical texts.
HT Brent Strawn
Der Ursprung der Kaige Rezension
Wolfgang Schütte has published a book on the origin of the Kaige recension.
Agade gives the following book information:
Wolfgang Schütte, “Der Ursprung der kaige Rezension. Mit einem Nachwort zu Ps.-Aristeas, Aristobul und der Torah”, 2026, 244 pages, BoD-Verlag Hamburg, ISBN 978-3-6957-2708-7 (hardcover, 69 €), ISBN 978-3-6957-0181-0 (softcover, 32 €)
The author unpicks the theological foundation that led to the formation of the kaige recension. It is theTorah, as set out in Deuteronomy and as a coherent narrative comprising the Five Books of Moses. The legal terminology in the Books of Kings holds the key. It reveals three stages in the Jewish history of law within the Books of Samuel and Kings, which also cast the textual history of these books in a new light.
Given that the coherent narrative of the Five Books of Moses did not take shape until the Hellenistic period, the Pseudo-Aristeas letter and the earliest historical accounts of the Mosaic Torah can be reinterpreted.
Contents:
Chapter 1 (hammiṣwah – a forgottenforerunner to the DeuteronomicTorah?) describes how theDeuteronomic Torah came into beingthrough the revision of an oldertextual source, the Deuteronomicmiswah. (A first version waspreviously published in ZAW 137[2025])
Chapter 2 (The Nature of the kaigeRecension. A response to the criticism by Tim McLay) sets out the historical linguistic contexts and the textual-historical foundations for the terms “statute” and “judgement” in the Book of Kings.
Chapter 3 (kaige and the relationship between the LXX and the ANT) incorporates the textual tradition of the Antiochene minority tradition into the interpretation of the LXX kaige recension.
Chapter 4 (Why is the Torah “Law”?) describes the cultural origins of Deuteronomy. Deuteronomy forms a discursive space within which all Jewish traditional legal systems must find their place. This task paves the way for the development of the Mishnah and the Gemara. Deuteronomy strives for a unified Jewish nomos as an alternative to the Greek concept of nomos.
Chapter 5 (Pseudo-Aristeas, Aristobulus and the Torah) interprets the Letter of Pseudo-Aristeas as a promotional text for the Deuteronomistic version of what is now a coherent narrative of the Five Books of Moses, and situates the remaining historical textual evidence concerning the Torah within this interpretative framework.